Pages

Monday, 17 March 2014

Editorial Commentary Analysis


This editorial commentary is part of the  BBC 4 programme A Point of View, it was broadcasted the 2nd of June of 2013.

At the very beginning of the commentary, we can hear a female voice presenting a show that will be broacasted other day and giving information about where we can find more episodes. After that, she introduces John Gray, the guest. This guy, starts the show with a fact, in a magic show we know we are beeing tricked and we like that, plus we don't want to feel as fool as we are asking the magician to repeat the trick so we can see how we were tricked.

This fact is connected with the movie The Great Gatsby, actually the main topic of the programme lies on the book/movie. Gatsby gets fool everyone, in an era where everything that counted were the appereances, to have money and things he was able of coming to the nowhere and have everything. The guest relates this with the desire of fantasy, Gatsby threw huge parties where people attend and they go there in order of forgeting their real problems. Because that was what people on that times wanted, live the fantasy, the opulence of that parties and the no revelation of the real selves.

The Gatsby case is also compared to the fake paintings because a fake painting to be really good it needs to have the little mistakes the real painter commit, because if not it would't be a good fake one. Same happens with Gatsby, the fake identity was so well build that no one could believe he was real. 

John Gray ends up with the same example that he started the show, the magician one. 

At the end of the programme we can hear the female voice of the beginning naming again the guest, and telling us who is the producer of the show. Also she informes us of who is coming next week and what is going to happen after the news and the following days.

Raquel Romero Morales

Feature




Editorial Commentary: Unknown knows

Unkown knows is a reflection by John Gray about facts and knows people rather to ignore: http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b03nt8br
It is produced by Sheila Cook

Broadcasted on Friday 10th January, 20:50 
and Sunday 12th January, 08:48 
in 2014 at BBC Radio 4's "Point of View"

John Gray is a professor of History who introduces the commentary speaking about the general thought of the economical crisis being part of the past and the situation being continuously getting better. Then he throws the rethorical question which would make the listener to keep tuned, curious: "Are we fooling oursevles?"

This professor distinguishes between things which are known but people do not pay attention to them, things that are not known and, finally, things which people do know but prefer to pretend to forget or ignore - i.e. things we choose not to know.
The first example is the Iraq war and the massive destruction weapons topic, which ended up to be just a justification. However, as Sadam was in some way linked to Al-Qaeda and the USA was expected to settle democracy in this country, no one has complained. The speech is not about what happned or did not happen, but about the fact that people rathers not to know, as it is more comfortable.
The second example is about the financial crisis and how, all along history, just before the crack everything was perfect. From a historical point of view, a crisis does not occur from day to night - there are many factors which indicate it and vaticcinates its advent long before it happens. However, people just ignores them, for it is easier to live in a not so realistic world. 

As a conclusion, he suggests that it is the system itself which provokes this evading-minded people, as it is the only way it can work. And, although all crisis and tragedies are similar to others which have already happened, people rather to forget and ignore.

It is remarkable that John Gray appeals to examples which are common and known by everybody -in fact, he does not give any data, just opinion- but no one really knows concretely about them, not even experts. Thus, he contacts with the listener, making him believe that this reasoning could have been developed by him or her.

Editorial Commentary - Alejandro Ordóñez

Okay. This is awkward. I didn't know this was supposed to be written down and I directly went for a podcast of myself analyzing the editorial live (which I honestly find more challenging and simply like it better). So let's just say I went the creative way.

Anyway, in case you find this is pure crap and has nothing to do with what we were supposed to do... it was just an honest mistake, so I apologize in advance.

Editorial: "Con la Reforma Fiscal ¿Vamos a pagar lo mismo o menos?" - Carlos Herrera

Me talking too much:

Sunday, 16 March 2014

Editorial Commentary Analysis


This editorial commentary belongs to the BBC Radio 4 programme A Point of View, and was first broadcasted on 29th October, 2010. 

It is presented by Sarah Dunant, paying a tribute to the female teachers who influenced her and the rest of students of her generation to become the women they are now. The editorial commentary begins just with the title of the programme and the name the presenter, without any more information about her, and then Sarah Dunant starts talking about two memorial services to which she had recently attended, both of two teachers she had in her years studying at school. She talks about these two women, their names and what were exactly their occupation, their interests and how they fought to provide girl students the same education than boys. She says that the two memorials were full of women who had been their students and thinks over how immense was their influence, linking this to personal experiences and anecdotes from her own life and to how these experiences with the teachers helped her grow as a person and not just to achieve a lot of information about history, literature, art, and the rest of the school subjects. These teachers educated them in life. 

Then, Dunant changes to a more general approach. She points out that the end of the war placed women again in their place as mothers and wives and had to left bigger dreams behind —she puts the example of her teachers wanting to have theaters and art galleries—, and that is why they decide to become teachers and pass their ideals to girls of the following generations, who would be the ones in charge of the next waves of feminism, and to convince them that they were as much capable of everything as boys. Dunant denounces that these women have not yet received the credit they deserve for their work towards equality. 

The presenter ends up claiming how important is the presence of teachers who inspire, in every period of history and both to boys and girls, and finishes —after a brief mention to the general debate on education— talking again about one of her teachers and some objects she left her, symbols for Dunant of the work of all women teachers and the inspiration they were for schoolgirls. 

The programme ends with the repeating of the name of the presenter, specifying that it was written by her, and the name of the producer. 


Begoña Martín Lara. 

Editorial Commentary Analysis.

Analysis of an Editorial Commentary (On Marriage)

Link to commentary: http://podbay.fm/show/292076787/e/1297458000?autostart=1


The editorial commentary I chose is part of a series of BBC Radio 4 show called "Point of View", and  it was broadcasted the 11th of February of 2011. 

In the commentary we will start hearing to the presenter introducing himself, Alan de Botton, and what we will hear in the next eleven minutes. After that, the presenter starts the commentary sharing one of his experiences in love in order to lead us to the hot point of the programme: the role of love in our lives and the situations we might have to face and deal with when you are in a relationship. 

However, the first part of the programme is quite more focus in how love is shown in literature and how, normally, love has to face several problems. How in literature there is a fascination with unrequited love and, with this, he applies the structure of love in novels to the real life, leading us to the second part of the programme in which he talks about the daily romantic life on marriage and how it's not as perfect as it is in novels, illustrating us with examples such us having different tastes, confrontations, discrepancies, etc in which the humor is key. 

He explains how, from his point of view, the representation of love in literature gives us a poor preparation for marriage, and how things are rather different when you have to live together with another person. That is when you realize the craze, the low logic of the actions of the other person; when you come to a point in which you need to be able to accept the other person as a whole. Finally the presenter sums up with the statement that marriage is never dull nor simple and that it "puts to shame the most passionate works of literature". 

So we can say that the programme's structure is divided in two parts, the first section in which he focus more on the role of love in literature, and the second section in which we can hear the application of his opinion to the real life and the comparison with literature.

The commentary ends with the presenter repeating his name, and the producer's, and giving us the link where we can find more programs, like the one we have been listening to, in case we are interesting in hearing it again or another one. 

Virginia Veros Moreno.

Editorial Commentary Individual Analysis


Analysis of an Editorial Commentary (Our Love for Animals)


This commetary is part of the BBC Radio 4 A Point of View. The particular episode was first broadcast the 28th of February of this year. I chose this programme because I’m a big advocate for animal rights issues, and thought this would be an interesting programme to listen to.
At the beginning of the programme, the presenters are still talking about a previous show. Then, without much of an introduction, they state the name of the commentarist, Roger Scruton, and he starts his commentary. There is no explanation as to who he is, probably because it is expected that the native listener’s know of him. After looking him up on-line, I found that he is one of the most important and controversial philosophers in Britain today, and leans clearly towards a Conservative position. All of this helped me understand why he said some of the things during the programme.
Scruton starts by describing where he lives, a small rural area, and the animals of the place. After presenting just how well human raised animals live, he introduces the dilemma of wildlife, and the many inconsistent actions that we take that put them in danger, like killing rodents but then trying to save owls and other animals that feed on them.  After a brief summary of the purely anthropogenic  causes for wildlife destruction, he goes on to the main issue of his commentary: pets. And this is were his commentary turns to being an essay on environmentalism to a very poetic argument about the different types of love that us humans may feel. He argues that people who are caught in childish types of love, who do not manage to discipline their emotions, do so because of their pets. At one point, he compares this to the love Hitler felt for his dogs. This statement seems to be added just for the dramatic touch of incluiding Hitler’s name in his commentary, but it doesn’t clarify anything and in fact has very little relation to what he is talking about.
After focusing on dogs, he starst to discuss about cats, for whom Scruton clearly has a particular dislike that he tries to transmit to the listener by pointing out that they are “the most destructive alien species of the country” (which he supports by giving some numeric facts) and that they have a “taste for blood”, and calls the animal conservation group RSCPA “inquisitors” for protecting stray cats despite the fact that they kill wildlife.
He finishes his commentary by stating that he understands the love and sense of duty that pet owners feel for their animals, and which is the reason why they don’t take into account the damage they cause on wildlife. With this, he gets the viewer back in his corner (since some of his previous claims might have offended pet owning listeners). He asks that people be aware that we do not only have a duty towards the animals we love as individuals, but also towards wildlife in general. This type of love directed towards a large group of species is “the hard kind of love”, and the one Scruton thinks we should have.
The programme ends repeating the name of the commentarist, in case anyone missed it at the beginning, and giving the name of the producer. After that, they announce the upcoming programmes. 

Alejandra Freund